Save the Berkeley Post Office
  • Home
    • Make a Video
  • Calendar
  • Contact
  • Activist's Guide

Federal Judge Dismisses Law Suits

4/16/2015

0 Comments

 
Picture
Attorneys left to right: Tony Rossmann (pro bono for the City of Berkeley), Zach Cowan (Berkeley City Attorney), Brian Turner (National Trust for Historic Preservation). Not pictured: Roger Moore (pro bono for the City of Berkeley).
SAN FRANCISCO, CA: On Tuesday, April 14, 2015, Judge William Alsup dismissed as “moot without prejudice to the filing of a new lawsuit when plaintiffs have suffered a cognizable injury” two cases from the City of Berkeley and the National Trust for Historic Preservation. Both legal actions asserted that the U.S. Postal Service has failed to comply with environmental and historic preservation laws while attempting to sell the Main Berkeley Post Office.

Statement from the Berkeley City Attorney's Office

While the cases were dismissed, the result of Judge Alsup’s order is actually quite favorable to the plaintiffs, because in order to render the cases moot, the USPS had to formally rescind its decision to relocate the post office from 2000 Allston Way.  The decision to relocate was the USPS’s first step in moving towards a sale. As a result, the USPS is back at square one, and there is no longer any decision to relocate postal services out of the Main Post Office at 2000 Allston Way.
 
Because the cases were dismissed as moot, the Judge did not rule on the merits, so all of our arguments about noncompliance with NEPA and NHPA remain intact and viable, and can be asserted if and when the USPS tries to sell the building again.  Judge Alsup also included in his order a provision that will prevent the USPS from selling the building without giving the City and the National Trust the opportunity to assert these challenges again:
 
The [USPS] must provide plaintiffs with written notice at least 42 calendar days in advance of the closing of any future sale of the Berkeley Main Post Office or any final determination to relocate retail post office services.
 
In a nutshell, Judge Alsup has effectively granted the City and National Trust the relief we requested by requiring USPS to make a binding commitment that its decisions to relocate and sell the post office have been rescinded.
 
All in all, while it is disappointing not to be able to litigate the NEPA and NHPA issues to a final judgment, the litigation has accomplished its primary goal of keeping the post office at 2000 Allston Way.

Limited Victory

Judge Alsup’s ruling protects Berkeley’s downtown post office from a secret sale.  Attorneys Tony Rossmann, pro bono attorney for the city of Berkeley, and Brian Turner of the National Trust for Historic Preservation, did great work.
But there’s no resolution to the issues. Had the case been heard on its merits, the federal courts would have spoken on whether the Postal Service must comply with historic preservation and environmental laws across the country. 
Congresswoman Barbara Lee has introduced a bill in the U.S. House of Representatives that will prevent the U.S. Postal Service from closing or selling any historic post office without the approval of Congress. With Lee’s bill and the documented failings of the Postal Service, we will continue to push the administrators of the U.S. Postal Service to hold up their responsibility to safeguard America’s historic post offices.

Recent chronology and links to latest documents

On March 26, 2015, Judge Alsup heard arguments in his courtroom at 450 Golden Gate in San Francisco on whether to dismiss the suits as moot.  At that time, Judge Alsup asked if the Postal Service intended to rescind its administrative decision “Final Determination on Relocation” to relocate/ sell Berkeley’s Main Post Office. Judge Alsup advised that his decision might be affected by whether or not the "Final Determination" had been rescinded.

The Postal Service responded on April 2, 2015, asserting that there was “no formal procedure for withdrawal of the 2013 Final Determination.” However, the Postal Service had indicated “that it would explore potential sales transactions that would include a lease-back provision, thereby allowing the Postal Service to lease a portion of the Berkeley Main Post Office for continued retail services.” As evidence of this, the Postal Service cited declarations of Diana Alvarado and of Joseph Lowe to the Court.
  • Document 54 filed April 2, 2015, Defendants "Notice of the Status of the USPS 2013 Final Determination"
  • Document 24 filed November 25, 2014, Declaration of Diana Alavarado
  • Document 24-1 filed November 25, 2014
  • Document 25, Declaration of Joseph Lowe

The City of Berkeley counter-responded on April 3, 2015. The court filing described to USPS response as “Lacking an authentic rescission, they provide a convoluted mirage designed to approximate one, which leaves in place the key decisions on which they relied to support sale of the property. It falls short in consistency, logic and law.”
  • Document 55 filed April 3, 2015, Plaintiff City of Berkeley's Initial Response to Notice of the Status of the USPS 2013 Final Determination

On April 14, Judge Alsup issued an “Order Dismissing the Case as Moot” and a “Judgement”.  In dismissing the case as moot, Judge Alsup stated that “if the USPS enters into a sale agreement for the property, and if plaintiffs contend that future agreement violates NEPA and the NHPA, then that case would not evade review.”
  • Document 56, April 14, 2015, Judge William Alsup, United States District Court, Order Dismissing Case as Moot
  • Document 57, April 14, 2015, Judge William Alsup, United States District Court, Judgment
0 Comments

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    ABOUT

    The USPS wants to sell Berkeley's historic main post office. Citizens to Save the Berkeley Post Office is a grassroots group that has come together to block the sale of our heritage, stop service cut backs, and preserve living wage postal jobs.

    Our fight is not unique. Thousands of post office closures across the country mean the largest private auction of public history our nation has ever seen.

    Join the movement and spread the word. Our post office is not for sale.

    Picture
    Ten Easy Steps
    to Making a Music Video
    to Save Your Post Office!


    Picture

    Picture
    Jac McCormick in NYC
    Fighting for America's
    Post Offices!
    WATCH THE VIDEO!


    Picture

    Tell Staples the U.S. Mail is Not for Sale!
    Picture
    Sign the petition to stop the sale of historic post office like Berkeley's Downtown Main!

    Picture
    Getting rid of middle class jobs is the end. Privatization is the means. Fox News doesn't keep their agenda a secret. Watch the video.

    [10 on Tuesday] 10 Ways to Fight for Your Local Post Office from PreservationNation

    October 2, 2013 letter from Ralph Nader to Senator Dianne Feinstein

    baha_letter_to_usps.pdf
    File Size: 222 kb
    File Type: pdf
    Download File

    sample_letter.docx
    File Size: 15 kb
    File Type: docx
    Download File


    Picture

    Archives

    May 2018
    March 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    August 2015
    July 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    May 2014
    December 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013
    January 2013

Proudly powered by Weebly